Okay so at a rodeo i met this kid. tall blond and super cute well i ran into a problem..?

I started to like him and than found out he is the brother to this other kid i like now im stuck between 2 brothers and dont know which one to choose. They have a messed up probablem of dating eachothers exs which is not going to happen with me. Ill date one but not the other but the problem is i have no idea which one to choose :*( they look nothing like eachother but they are completely like eachother. One of them is playing the whole date my brother, than 10 min later i want you to be my gf, than date me brother. i think he is trying to play games with me and the other is like look my brother is a date me.. ugh idk what the **** to do! i got myself into one hell of a prediciment because im going to have to see both of them since they live to gether.